How to choose a Google Ads agency for a criminal defense firm

How to Choose a Law Firm Google Ads Agency: 12 Questions, Red Flags and Pricing (Criminal Defense)

Most criminal defense lawyers have hired at least one marketing agency that sent good-looking reports while the phone stayed quiet, or rang with calls nobody could use. The problem usually started before the contract was signed: nobody asked the questions that separate an agency that signs cases from one that sells clicks.

Here are the twelve questions I’d ask any Google Ads agency or freelancer before letting them spend a defense firm’s money, and what a good answer sounds like. Yes, I run one. Use these on me too.

Questions about results

1. “How do you measure success?”

Good answer: signed cases and fees, by campaign. Red flag: clicks, impressions, click-through rate, or “conversions” with no link to signed matters.

2. “Can you show me cost per signed case for a defense firm you’ve worked with?”

Good answer: real numbers, with how they were measured. For example: $146,851 in ad spend, $496,700 in signed fees, 140 cases, $1,049 per case, with revenue from the firm’s case management system. Red flag: only lead counts or cost per lead.

3. “What happened in an account where results got worse?”

Good answer: a specific story and what they learned. Red flag: nothing ever went wrong. In my own work, raising a budget to $24,085 in a month returned only 2.2×, and that taught me to raise budget only where searches already sign.

Questions about how they work

4. “Who will actually run my account?”

Good answer: a named person, the one on your calls. Red flag: a salesperson now, an account manager later, and someone else doing the work.

5. “How many criminal defense firms do you work with in my city?”

Good answer: none, or a clear policy against it. Red flag: several. Firms competing for the same searches shouldn’t share a manager.

6. “How will you connect calls to signed cases?”

Good answer: call tracking that keeps the click ID, lead source and fee in your case management system, and signed cases sent back to Google Ads. Here’s what that setup looks like. Red flag: “we track calls.”

7. “How will you organize my campaigns?”

Good answer: by charge, with a matching landing page for each. Red flag: one campaign for “criminal lawyer.”

8. “What will you do in the first 30 days?”

Good answer: fix tracking, cut waste from the search terms, competitor names and wrong locations, and match landing pages to charges. Red flag: “launch and let the algorithm learn.”

9. “Will you listen to my intake calls?”

Good answer: yes, because missed and badly handled calls lose cases the ads already paid for. Red flag: “that’s not our job.”

Questions about money and terms

10. “What do you charge, and is it tied to my ad spend?”

Good answer: clear, published pricing. Percentage-of-spend pricing is common; just know that it rewards spending more, so pair it with signed-case reporting. Red flag: pricing you only hear after three calls.

11. “Who owns the ad account and the data?”

Good answer: you do. The Google Ads account, call tracking and landing pages stay yours if you leave. Red flag: the agency owns the account.

12. “How long is the contract, and why?”

Good answer: a short first term with a reason. Cases sign one to three months after the first call, so about 90 days is a fair test, then month-to-month. Red flag: a year-long lock-in.

Specialist criminal defense agency vs. general law firm agency vs. in-house

OptionStrengthsWatch out for
Criminal defense PPC specialistKnows charge-level economics, night and weekend intake, bail and public-defender search waste, bar advertising rules.Small specialists may cap how many firms they take; ask about exclusivity in your city.
General law firm marketing agencyOne vendor for website, SEO and ads; often good with personal injury.Defense accounts can get PI playbooks: broad keywords, lead counts, long contracts.
General PPC agency or freelancerCan be strong technically and cheaper.Rarely knows what a signed defense case is worth or how to track it to Clio or MyCase.
In-house hireFull attention and knowledge of your firm.One person’s salary often exceeds agency fees, and you lose outside benchmarks.

Weighing a single specialist against a bigger company? See Google Ads freelancer vs. agency for criminal defense lawyers, including what changes for solo lawyers.

What law firm Google Ads management costs

Agencies price Google Ads management in a few common ways. None is automatically better; what matters is that the fee doesn’t reward the agency for the wrong thing.

  • Flat monthly fee. Predictable, and doesn’t push the agency to raise your budget.
  • Percentage of ad spend. Scales with the work, but can reward spending more rather than signing more. Ask how they decide when not to raise budget.
  • Hybrid (a minimum or a percentage, whichever is greater). Common for smaller specialists. Bellringer uses this: $1,500 a month or 10% of ad spend, whichever is greater, details here.
  • Pay per lead or per case. Sounds safe, but check who owns the account, the phone numbers and the data, and how a “lead” is defined.

Also ask about setup fees, minimum terms and notice periods. A first term of around 90 days is reasonable, because cases take one to three months to sign; a 12-month lock-in usually isn’t.

Red flags when hiring a law firm PPC agency

  • They report clicks, impressions and “conversions” but never signed cases or fees.
  • You don’t own the Google Ads account, or they won’t give you admin access.
  • Call tracking numbers belong to them and stop working if you leave.
  • They promise a ranking, a number of cases or a cost per lead before seeing your account.
  • They run the same campaigns for personal injury, family law and criminal defense.
  • They work with several defense firms competing for the same county.
  • Long contracts with large cancellation fees.

Who should own the account, the numbers and the data

You should. The Google Ads account, the Google Analytics property, the call tracking account and the landing pages should be in your firm’s name, with the agency given access. If you change agencies, your history, conversion data and phone numbers stay with you, and the next manager doesn’t start from zero.

A quick scorecard

AreaGreen flagRed flag
ReportingSigned cases and feesClicks and impressions
Who does the workThe person you metAn account manager relay
CompetitorsOne firm per citySeveral firms in your market
StructureCampaigns and pages by chargeOne generic campaign
OwnershipYou own everythingThey own the account
TermsShort first term, then month-to-monthLong lock-in

For context on what results look like, read real cost per signed case from 140 defense cases or the 28-point audit checklist.

How do I choose a Google Ads agency for my law firm?

Ask how they measure success (it should be signed cases and fees), ask for a cost per signed case from a firm like yours, confirm you will own the account and call tracking, check whether they work with competing firms in your area, and avoid long lock-in contracts.

What is the best Google Ads agency for criminal defense lawyers?

The best fit is a specialist that measures results in signed cases, understands charge-level fees and after-hours intake, lets you own your account and data, and works with only one defense firm in your market.

How much does a law firm PPC agency cost?

Common models are a flat monthly fee, a percentage of ad spend, a hybrid of the two, or pay per lead. Bellringer charges $1,500 a month or 10% of ad spend, whichever is greater, with a 90-day first term and then month-to-month.

Should a criminal defense firm use a specialist agency?

Usually yes. Defense searches, fees and intake work differently from personal injury or family law, and a general agency often applies the wrong playbook: broad keywords, lead counts and long contracts.

Should I own my Google Ads account?

Yes. The ad account, analytics, call tracking numbers and landing pages should belong to your firm, with the agency given access. That protects your data and phone numbers if you ever change agencies.

What questions should I ask a Google Ads agency?

How do you measure success? Can you show cost per signed case for a defense firm? Who works on my account? Do I own it? How do you handle negative keywords and after-hours calls? Do you work with competitors in my city? What are the terms to leave?

Get a straight answer on your account

Want to ask me these questions? Book a free 30-minute account review. I’ll look at your search terms, your call recordings and what you signed last quarter, and tell you where the money is leaking, whether you hire me or not. I work with one criminal defense firm per city and 12 firms at most.

Or call Henry directly at 612-203-3591. See pricing or the full Amari Law Firm results.

Henry Bell runs Bellringer Marketing, a Google Ads practice that works only with criminal defense firms. He managed paid search and Local Services Ads for Amari Law Firm in Birmingham, Alabama, from September 2025 to August 2026, reporting results in signed cases from the firm’s case management system.

More Guides for Criminal Defense Firms